Gary makes a promise he can't keep to Louise when he tries to one-up Allison's rich new boyfriend (Ron Huebel) in gift giving.

Cast: Jay Mohr, Paula Marshall, Keegan-Michael Key, Brooke D'Orsay, Ryan Malgarini, Kathryn Newton, David Douglas, Rob Huebel, Allan Murray, Rob Riggle, Adria Tennor, Vincent M. Ward