When Gary's plan to help Tom land a spot on the wrestling team backfires, he challenges the coach, a former high school nemesis, to a wrestling rematch in an attempt to settle their score.

Cast: Jay Mohr, Paula Marshall, Keegan-Michael Key, Brooke D'Orsay, Ryan Malgarini, Kathryn Newton, David Koechner, Travis T. Flory, Ellen Wroe, Shawn McGill