This week, the teams must create their own puppets and perform in front of a live audience for Henson Alternative's "Stuffed and Unstrung" improv show. One outspoken Celebrity struggles to be a team player. On the other team, another Celebrity fights for a role in the task, but is marginalized and has a breakdown. Both teams put their improvisational skills to the test, but only one is declared the winner.

Cast: Donald Trump, Penn Jillette, Deborah Gibson, Arsenio Hall, Dayana Mendoza, Adam Carolla, Tia Carrere, Lisa Lampanelli, Lou Ferrigno, Paul Teutul Sr., Patricia Velasquez, Victoria Gotti, Michael Andretti, Cheryl Tiegs, Dee Snider