The firm's newest attorney, Anita Haskins (Toni Trucks), takes point on a seemingly simple divorce case, but when it's revealed that the plaintiff is married to a plastic surgeon who's been subletting at the firm (guest star Willie Garson), Peter and Jared step in to ensure they don't lose the much needed revenue stream. They guys must now win the case by proving the surgeon cheated on her -- with her. Also, a promise to score tickets to a highly anticipated baseball game sends the boys calling in favors all over town leading to a kiss Peter or Jared will never forget. Creed Bratton also guest stars.

Cast: Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Breckin Meyer, Reed Diamond, Toni Trucks, Anthony Ordonez, Regi Davis, Christine Donlon, Ken Garito, Lindsey Gentile, Joyce Greenleaf, Jennifer Robyn Jacobs, Ricardo Mamood-Vega, Erin Ross, Azie Tesfai, Jason Tobias