The three finalists are tasked with creating a creature that will interact in a scene with others and must include a prop and a special effect. The setting is a roadside tavern where their three strange creatures will meet and share their stories. Eliminated competitors return to help the finalists complete their biggest challenge yet.

Cast: Jake Corrick, Melissa Doss, Chaz Vance, Robert H. Bennett, Tina Roland, Ben Bayouth, Lex Rudd, Russ Adams, Ivonne Escoto, Josh Smith, Gigi Edgley, Brian Henson, Beth Hathaway, Kirk R. Thatcher, Peter Brooke