When Jessica asks/demands Andy to pick up her nephew Jake after soccer practice, he picks up the wrong kid. Soon the real Jake turns out to be a terror and Andy wishes he'd stuck with Fake Jake instead.

Cast: Andy Richter, Paget Brewster, Irene Molloy, Jonathan Slavin, James Patrick Stuart, Marilu Henner, John Bliss, Martin Spanjers, Conrad Bachmann, Victoria Fischer, Cory Parravano, John Douglas Williams