The sorceress gives the guests a somewhat pleasant surprise; The guests must free 2 children, before the time runs out, and the gingerbread lady is released; 2 guests are put into a challenge; Someone is going to die.

Cast: Joey Graceffa, Liza Koshy, Jesse Wellens, Tyler Oakley, Andrea Russett, Alex Wassabi, Lauren Riihimaki, DeStorm Power, Gabbie Hanna, Tana Mongeau, Eva Augustina Sinotte, Lindsay Elston, Rika Pinto, Jackie Zane, Armaan Kohil