Feeling she has no hope to advance in the competition Alex just quits. But it turns out that mortals and werewolves can't date because the werewolf always eats the human so they ha e to break up. Meanwhile Max is voted most elegible wizard and cat he's the eye of a young Cucuy, a Spanish monster.

Cast: Selena Gomez, David Henrie, Jake T. Austin, Jennifer Stone, Maria Canals-Barrera, David DeLuise, David Barrera, Samantha Boscarino, Roxana Brusso, Andy Kindler, Frank Pacheco, RJ Smith-Tillman, Gregg Sulkin, Kari Wahlgren