Callie finds a lost puppy belonging to one of their elderly neighbors, but when Adam unintentionally takes credit for rescuing the puppy, the neighbor shows her appreciation to Adam almost too generously. When Lisa complains about the noise coming from their music-blasting neighbor, Mike's plan to confront his neighbor and ensure peace and quiet takes an unexpected turn. Meanwhile, Ethan's girlfriend takes interest in meeting his wise next-door neighbor face-to-face.

Cast: David Denman, Nelson Franklin, Kris Marshall, Liza Lapira, Aya Cash, Janina Gavankar, Malcolm Barrett, Lorna Raver, T.J. Miller, David King, Ankur Bhatt, Annie Korzen, Stephanie Y. Wang