A community is rattled when a politician's son, who was presumed murdered years ago, returns home.
Cast: Joan Allen, Rupert Graves, Alison Pill, Margot Bingham, Zach Gilford, Liam James, Floriana Lima, Madeleine Arthur, Rarmian Newton, Andrew McCarthy, Felix Solis, Grant Show, Matthew Lawler, Maxwell James, Michael Esper
Nina closes in on Jane. Claire suffers an emotional breakdown when visiting Ben and Adam's prison. Secrets finally arise.
Willa tells Claire an awful secret just as the election results are announced; Agent Clements tries to convince Jane to free him; Ben shares shocking news with Willa; Bridey contemplates using the dirt she's dug up on Warrens to make the front page; Nina strives to get Doug to confess. Meanwhile, flashbacks chronicle Hank's fall to social pariah.
In an ironic twist, Hank believes he has key evidence to help Nina solve Adam's case, and, more importantly, make himself a hero. Willa's suspicions about Ben intensify when she makes a shocking discovery about what really happened to Adam.
Claire deals with the ramifications of Willa's scheming; Nina tracks Adam, who disappears every night from his home; Clements investigates Jane's link to the pock-marked man; the governor's wife threatens to reveal Claire's drinking; and Hank makes a discovery about Adam's kidnapping.
Flashbacks show Adam's return to Red Pines set against the backdrop of Willa's secrets and lies; what Adam went through in captivity; and Hank's state of mind while incarcerated. In other events, John drops a bombshell on Claire, which forces her to make a difficult decision about the future of her family.
Determined to find the kidnapper, Nina devises a dangerous plan to capture him. Willa struggles with her feelings for Bridey, who reveals the shocking truth of Adam's identity.
Hank is attacked and names a Warren as the prime suspect; Bridey learns the results of the paternity test she ran on Adam; and Adam receives postcards from the pock-marked man. In other events, in the past, John's grief leads to his affair with Nina.
Detective Meyer and Agent Clements go on the hunt for a child kidnapper whose MO is eerily similar to Adam's abductor. Meanwhile, Bridey continues to infiltrate the Warren family, searching for intel on Adam, but arouses Willa's suspicions when she is caught prowling around the house uninvited.
Despite Claire's objections, Adam agrees to return to the bunker to see if anything will trigger his memory, but it becomes evident he is hiding something.
Secrets and suspicions threaten the Warren family, while Detective Myers is determined to correct mistakes of the past.
10 years ago, Adam Warren disappeared. Today, he finally returns and not all the family members are handling his return well.