Interviews with friends, family and Sally McNeil herself chart a bodybuilding couple's rocky marriage and its shocking end in a Valentine's Day murder.
Cast: Peggy Hook, John McNeil, Sally McNeil, Shantina McNeil, Shannon Brown, Dan Goldstein, DJ Jeffers, Debrosha McCants, William Rafael, Lenda Murray, Diane Dimond, Wayne DeMillia, Rachel Louise Snyder, Melanie Jeffers, Nancy Kaser-Boyd, Hugh Malay, Lee Penman, Bill Wick
Sally's trial attracts a media frenzy when it begins on Valentine's Day, 1996. Later, following Sally's testimony, the jury renders a verdict.
After Ray's death lurid details of the McNeils' volatile marriage emerge and Sally's claims of self-defense meet new scrutiny.
Sally and Ray McNeil meet and fall in love via a shared interest in bodybuilding. But their seemingly happy marriage masks a life of violence and abuse.